So you've bought yourself an Obamacare Bronze health plan. Congratulations! Now consider: what if you get sick?
Let's assume for the moment that you've chosen a plan that actually covers visits to real doctors, in your area, who are accepting patients. Your expenses are 60% covered! What, really, does that mean?
Well... consider this. If you had one of those nasty old plans with 100% coverage, you'd pay nothing out of pocket, and the third-party payer (I refuse to call them "insurance companies" in this context) would pay... er... right around 10% of the bill, typically. The other 90% of the bill, nobody really expected to be paid anyway.
With your modern comprehensive "real insurance" plan's 60% coverage, you have 40% "coinsurance", i.e., you pay 40% of the bill.
Which is four times the total amount that would have been paid under the old plan, right?
And it seems that the ACPA's fine print somehow repealed long-standing laws against kickbacks... anyone wondering what's going to happen? Anyone?
Nobody from either party seems to be questioning what things ought to cost, as, e.g., Tom McClintock did with regard to education budgets a few years back. Well, his work was widely ignored, so perhaps there's no point.
Just for kicks, though, let's make some wild assumptions and try to get a handle on what a routine doctor visit ought to cost.
Let's see, now. We've got one high-skill worker and one medium-skill worker, each with continuing-education requirements. Call the annual cost of employment, say, $200K and $125K respectively.
We've got an examining room. Basically a broom closet, in a building with a receptionist. Call it 100 square feet at $10/sq ft/month, so $12K/year.
We've got some moderately-specialized equipment, with useful lifetimes from 3 years to 25 years. Allow $50K/year depreciation for the lot.
This comes to $387K/year. Call it $400K.
If we assume 2000 working hours/year for doctor, nurse, room, and equipment, this gives us $200/hour.
Since routine doctor visits are scheduled in quarter-hour chunks, one quarter-hour visit ought to cost about $50.
Eternal Emperor's list price for an office visit this year is $331, whereof 40% is $132.40.
So, by my BOTE calculation, they're only overbilling (for a routine visit) by a bit over a factor of six; assuming the price doesn't change next year (yeah, right), the Bronze Plan $60 copay for the first three visits should actually be the entire payment, including profit, while the 40% coinsurance after that is about 2.6 times what a doctor visit would cost if we just burned down the whole damn third-party payer system and paid cash for routine health care at free-market prices.
And that, kids, is why, in the Great Recession and with people losing their jobs and their employer-provided health plans left and right, it was necessary to pass this monstrosity of lobbyist-written legislation to force everyone back into The System. Because otherwise we'd be seeing spontaneous, free-market reform, and the masses might realize that they didn't need The System, and hadn't all along.
Recent Comments