So here it is, another bill-paying morning; only one that actually needs mailing today, and others that can wait until next week.
On my Bank of Italy Master Charge bill, I see something new: $8.10 Foreign Transaction Fee. WTF??? They never used to charge me for that. Is this some new scam to make up for the fees they can't charge under the Doddering-Fink Law?
Then there's this thing from my HMO. To avoid getting too specific, I'll refer to the general practitioner as GP, the physical therapist as PT, and the HMO as Emperor. All clear?
OK, so: when I went to see GP for the leg thing, there was a $30 copay. On each of the two visits to PT, there was a $55 copay. Each time, I used a credit card.
Then I get this here bill thing, from the Emperor of Nothern California's accounting department in Alabama:
Provider
|
Description
|
Charges
|
Paid by Insurance
|
Paid by You
|
Amount You Owe
|
GP
|
Office visit
|
331.00
|
301.00
|
30.00
|
0.00
|
PT
|
Evaluation
|
245.00
|
112.00
|
55.00
|
78.00
|
PT
|
PT: each 15 mins, therapeutic
|
100.00
|
45.00
|
|
55.00
|
PT
|
PT: each 15 mins, therapeutic
|
100.00
|
45.00
|
|
55.00
|
Then there's another item that shows a $55 copay not yet processed. So, they're billing me for $188, of which I already paid $55, and it looks like the $55 copay for the first visit was mistakenly credited to the line item for PT "evaluation," which... er... does that mean reading my medical record, or was it part of the first session?
So, lessee now. The basic GP office visit (under 15 minutes) is billed at $331.00, or $1324/hour. The PT sessions (basically office visits) are billed at $400/hour.
Well, there's your problem!
Emperor Third-Party Payment's captive Provider Network is billing outrageous amounts for routine services. Since Emperor TPP and Emperor PN are part of the same corporation, it's all a matter of shuffling cash from one pocket to another (and you should see how much they charge themselves for their unionized employees' heath plan!), but...
Well, for one thing, my Cadillac-priced health plan (by always choosing the lowest-premium option when offered a choice, I've kept my premium down to a little over $10,000 for this year) apparently only has 45% coverage for physical therapy. And if my share is $55/15 minutes, or $220/hour... just how much is PT getting paid, anyway? Do physical therapists take home anything like $440K/year, never mind the $800K/year implied by the nominal charge?
Surely I could find a physical therapist in private practice who'd charge less than $220/hour, cash... right?
And that $1324/hour for the doctor, all but the copay covered by the plan... well. You know how, under Obamacare, 80% of all premiums must go to paying for health care services? Hey, look! If Emperor PN sets its rates high enough, there's no problem showing 80% of Emperor TPP's incoming premiums being paid out to the PN for health care services.
And, under our glorious third-party payment system, the amounts billed and the amounts paid are largely unrelated, and neither has any connection to what health care ought to cost in a sane world where people were paying real bills with their own real money, and being mindful of how much they were paying, and for what.
The wonderful efficiency provided by an HMO allows all this obfuscation to happen under a single corporate umbrella, with internal billing and payment processing handled in just the same way as in the inefficient outside-the-HMO system.
Time to sign off, before someone reports me to the Mental Hygiene Police.
Recent Comments